Skip to Content

Do you have money dysmorphia?

Reader Reese posted this Yahoo article in the Frugal Girl Facebook group yesterday, and I thought it would be fun to discuss here.

(Thanks, Reese!)

piggy bank.

Money dysmorphia refers to the experience of having a “distorted perception of your financial situation that doesn’t match reality.”

Unlike body dysmorphia, money dysmorphia is not actually diagnosable. But it could be an interesting label for the way some of us think about our money. 

Basically, it’s a mismatch between how you feel and what is actually, factually true.

You might feel like you have lots of money (“woohoo, let’s buy everything!”) when you actually do not have a lot of money.

Or (and this might be true for more of us here!), you might have plenty of money but feel like you do not have nearly enough.

piggy bank.

The article didn’t touch on this, but what occurred to me is that money dysmorphia could be a very understandable response to a period of life where you truly haven’t had enough money.

If you’ve been scrimping and pinching just to survive for a long time and then you finally reach a place of more financial stability, it could be hard for your brain to adjust to the new reality.

It must be a little like the way people feel when they lose a significant amount of weight; they find themselves still thinking they are in their bigger bodies, even though they are not.

My almost-broke period of life

I thought of the recent years of my life…as you know, I left my marriage, moved into a rental house, and spent several years being not too far from broke. 

Kristen's rental on moving day.

My divorce took two years, during which time I paid painful sums of money to my divorce lawyer. Also, during this time I was not getting alimony (obviously that happens after a divorce!) or child support (Zoe turned 18 shortly after the divorce was finalized, so she was a minor during the whole process).

A single income + a high rental market + endless lawyer bills is not a recipe for wealth, let me tellllll you. 😉

I was doing my best to be frugal, of course; as you know, I furnished my new house largely with items from the Treasure House and from my Buy Nothing groups, I applied for scholarships to cover my school bills, and I did all my usual frugal things like cooking at home.

View of Kristen's living room.

But still…it was financially tight there for a while. I actually did run out of money and I had to open some 0% interest rate credit cards toward the end of my divorce process, just to cover the legal fees until the divorce finalized.

black high heels.

Waiting for the final divorce hearing, in uncomfortable shoes

Anyway, the divorce finalization was just over a year ago, and I must say, it is a delightful experience to not be almost-broke anymore. It is wild how much more money you have when you are not paying a lawyer. Ha. 

Most of the time, I think my brain does recognize the reality that I am in a better financial place. But I will also admit that there are times when I find myself spending an inordinate amount of time trying to figure out a way to save something like $10 on a purchase.

And then I have to remind myself: it’s ok. Ten dollars isn’t a make-or-break thing. Sometimes the right choice is to just throw money at a problem, and I now have enough wiggle room to do that.

Maybe I need a fun budget

Reading this article made me think: perhaps I need a little monthly fun budget, just to remind my brain that I am not actually broke.

I haven’t really budgeted at all since my divorce; it’s just me, myself, and I running my finances and it’s not like I need guardrails to keep my spending in check. Ha.

Kristen looking tired.

at a waiting room for a mediation appointment, wearing a clearance-purchased sweater I’ve had since 2011.

Kristen in white sweater.

the same sweater, on the way to the symphony!

But budgets can be helpful reminders to not just save money, but also to spend it. For very frugal people like me, the process of setting aside money with the express purpose of using it for something fun is really helpful.

Otherwise, we can just be in save, save, save mode and then we miss out on some of the joyful things and experiences that money can buy.

Soooooo, maybe I’ll give myself a little monthly sum of money and assign myself to job of spending it on something that is just fun.

Maybe $50/month? Is that too little, do you think? I don’t even know!

What about you? Do you have money dysmorphia (either type!)?

And you can also give me opinions about how much I should budget for some fun spending. 🙂

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Ruth

Wednesday 29th of January 2025

This is EXACTLY what happened with my parents and others who lived through the Great Depression! No matter how much they actually had, they FELT poor. They used to tell us kids that we couldn't afford this or that - even really small things. It was just a knee-jerk reaction.

I used to wonder why it was called the Great Depression - it didn't sound terribly "great" to me. But back in the day, "great" and "grand" simply meant "BIG."

Selena

Tuesday 28th of January 2025

I am going to throw out the question to you - retirement funds. You were married for ten years so you could collect half your ex's SS, full amount if he dies - and so could his current wife OR any other ex's to whom he was married 10 years. Interesting isn't it but I digress. It may be tough to know what your half would be (but maybe your lawyer had a figure at the time). Good chance you'll get in your 40 quarters but will drawing on your own account be more than 1/2 your ex's? When it comes to living in poverty/at the poverty level in retirement, women are still the majority. Not saying have no fun, just crunch some numbers and be honest. I watched two sets of grandparents (males had pensions that were soo offset by their SS it wasn't funny) struggle in retirement - regardless of money management. I started saving for retirement when I turned 18. At age 21, I had a banker tell me I was "too young to worry about retirement". I ignored him.

Selena

Tuesday 28th of January 2025

@Selena, @Kristen - fully understanding you might have received a QDRO of pension/401k/403b

Kristina

Tuesday 28th of January 2025

Interesting question. Being poor carries a deep anxiety for a long time; worrying about managing abundance is very different. But if you can cover your basic needs, you are OK. For fun, think of what you enjoy and invest in itโ€”symphony series tickets, follow up on a hobby and improve (garden, furniture construction and design, cooking, needle arts, photography). Buy a museum membership and attend regularly to see new shows, hear curator talks, etc. Or deepen an interest: I LOVE geography and am a good traveler through appreciation of cultural and physical geography. I also enjoy talks and films at art museums, and special exhibits. Life is too short to work all the time, and as an adult you have more agency for recreation. Dance class? Volunteer in a cause important to you? Support music education in public schools? Having fun sometimes gives you a window on your best self, even new ideas for who you want to be tomorrow.

Selena

Tuesday 28th of January 2025

Nothing wrong with mad money. I was at a fundraising auction one time, I had a couple grand in mad money. Well the woman bidding against me was an established physician hence my money wasn't mad enough. She was bound and determined to win (she was a consistent, generous supporter of the organization) which she did. But we had fun as did the auctioneer. Kudos to you for being able to open credit cards during your getting divorce period. I remember a woman from my town who got divorced (had four minor children). This was before the laws were changed re: credit scores etc. Despite having utilities with her soon-to-be ex-husband, she ended having to put down deposits (her folks helped her out). Sad to say, too many want us to go back to the era where a woman was totally dependent on a male. Not on my watch.

Mary

Tuesday 28th of January 2025

When I was trying to balance frugality, savings, and fun, I gave myself a percentage of my income to spend. It was easier for my brain to understand a portion for savings, some for necessities, a bit to give generously, and some just for fun.

Tomorrow isn't promised and good things in life are worthwhile today. So, if it's 1% of your paycheck, or $50 or some other way to choose, it's worth spending on things that make you happy. Full price symphony tickets. Ice cream. A brand new book by an author you want to support. Take out after a hard shift. Really nice socks. Whatever makes like delightful.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.