Skip to Content

The 2019 Cookie Guessing Game!

Alrighty, readers. It’s time!

Christmas cookie

Joshua wasn’t able to join us this year, so I just have five cookies for you, which should make things very slightly easier.

Christmas cookie

I was going to point out that Lisey will eventually move out and probably not join us as well.


When I said this to Lisey, she assured me that even if she moves to Florida (her dream), she will still fly back specifically to decorate cookies with us. 😉

Christmas cookie

If you’re new to my blog, you should know that at our house, Christmas cookies are not at all traditional.

Christmas cookie

a bell who is a chimney sweep

We have traditionally-shaped cookie cutters, but that’s where it ends.

Christmas cookie

Also, most of our cookies have faces. 😉

Here are this year’s choice cookies.

Cookie 1

A Christmas tree with some stylishly heavy eyebrows.

Christmas cookie

The cookie artist said that this was Mr. FG as a Christmas tree, since Mr. FG has pretty massive eyebrows.

Cookie 2

A hammerhead shark, made from a candy cane cookie.

Christmas cookie

I bought the goldfish sprinkles specifically because they are exactly the kind of non-traditional thing we decorate with. Ha.

Cookie 3-the one with a long backstory

This one is a lonely vampire, who has lived so long that all his friends have passed on.

To add to his misery, his workplace is having the Christmas party during the day, and since he’s a vampire, he can’t attend.

Thus: a heart-broken Christmas tree cookie.

Christmas cookie

Cookie 4

Pretty self-explanatory…Patrick Star from Sponge Bob.

Christmas cookie

Cookie 5

These are shark fins in the midst of a goldfish feeding frenzy.

Christmas cookie

I don’t really think that many sharks could fit into such a small space, but we are suspending disbelief here. 😉

Ok! So, here are the numbered cookies.

Christmas cookie

And the cookie artists are:

  • Kristen
  • Mr. FG
  • Lisey
  • Sonia
  • Zoe

So, leave your guess in this format:

1-cookie artist
2-cookie artist

and so on.

That way I can easily keep track of who gets the order right first!

First one to guess the correct order gets a $50 Amazon gift card emailed to them, courtesy of me.

And if no one gets it right after 24 hours, I’ll give the gift card to the first person who got closest.

Ready, set, go!

P.S. The cookie and frosting recipe we used every year is available right here.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Sandy Jones

Monday 16th of December 2019

1- Mr. FG 2- Sonia 3- Lisey 4- Kristen 5- Zoe


Saturday 14th of December 2019

1- Sonia 2- Lisey 3- Mr FG 4- Kristen 5- Zoe


Saturday 14th of December 2019

1-Mr FG 2-Zoe 3-Sonia 4-Kristen 5-Lisey


Saturday 14th of December 2019

1. Lisey 2. Sonia 3. Kristen 4. Zoe 5. Mr. FG


Saturday 14th of December 2019

1. Kristen 2. Zoe 3. Lisey 4. Mr. FG 5. Sonia

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.