Skip to Content

How to make panini sandwiches

Today I thought I’d share how I make panini, since multiple readers have been asking me about this.

Panini are a great way to use up odds and ends of food (yay for avoiding food waste!)…you can use pretty much any combination of meats, vegetables, and cheeses and still end up with a tasty sandwich.

I don’t imagine that my method is THE correct panini-making method (if there is such a thing!), but it works for us.

I start with a loaf of homemade French bread.

You most certainly can use other breads, though…I’ve used sandwich bread and whole wheat bread in the past, and the sandwiches were delicious. And if you aren’t inclined to make your own bread, a sturdy purchased bread will work well too. Just make sure that the bread isn’t too soft, or it will squish down into nothingness when you try to make it into a panini.

I don’t actually own a panini-maker…I have a pan with ridges in the bottom that I got as a hand-me-down, so I put my sandwiches in that and I use a cast-iron skillet as a weight to do the, um, squishing.

I am sure there is a better term for that.

Maybe “pressing”?

Anyway, while I’m prepping the sandwiches, I put both pans on the stove over medium heat.

I cut the bread into slices about 3/4 inch thick.

You can also slice the bread lengthwise, as I did in this older post (scroll down to see the sandwich). This is a little more authentic, I think, but we all kind of prefer our paninis to be made with regular slices of bread.

I lay my bread slices out and put sliced cheese on each piece of bread. You could put cheese on only one side but I find that having it on both sides helps the sandwich to stay together a little better.

After that, I add whatever filling I happen to have around.

Roast beef and mushrooms are my husband’s favorite.

I had sauteed peppers and onions left from our Chicken Tacos, so that’s what I put in mine.

Incidentally, I’m having a love affair with sauteed onions right now. I don’t really love raw onions, but my goodness! When they’re sauteed with a little butter and sprinkled with a bit of salt, they are so, so good.

Cilantro pesto with chicken makes a good filling (I usually add some mayo when I use that combo), and so do ham and cheese. In the summer, I like to combine chicken, fresh, seeded tomato slices, sauteed onion, and basil. And of course, just cheese works very well too.

Anyhow. I close up the sandwich and then butter both sides of the sandwich.

I then place the sandwich(es) into the heated grill pan.

And I put the heated cast iron pan right on top of the sandwiches. This would work a little bit better if I had a larger cast-iron pan, but my other one is so big, it won’t fit into my grill pan.

I cook the sandwiches for 3-5 minutes, or until they look browned, and then I flip them over, place the cast iron skillet back on top, and cook them until the cheese is melted and the underside is browned.

So tasty! I kind of want one for breakfast now (speaking of which, you can make paninis with eggs and cheese for breakfast).

If you don’t own a ridged pan, you can make your paninis in a regular, flat frying pan. Just use something heavy (bricks wrapped in foil work as well as a heavy pan) to weigh the sandwiches down.

Of course, there’s also the option of buying a real panini press (if you want to go that route, Cook’s recommends a Krups version), but since using what you already have is free, I’d recommend giving that a try first. 😉

How do you make panini?

If you’ve got another alternate cooking method, do share! And if you’ve discovered a particularly tasty filling combination, share that too…I’m always looking for new panini ideas.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Reba L Patches

Saturday 27th of April 2019

A cookie sheet with a Strong's concordance on top is my panini maker. I like to use this method for reubens since there are so many ingredients to melt together.


Saturday 27th of April 2019

Haha, I know exactly what a Strong's concordance is, and I can imagine that working very well.


Friday 26th of April 2019

I use my waffle iron as a panini grill. No need for a panini specific kitchen tool. Yes, the sandwiches have a waffle pattern rather than classic panini stripes but they taste the delicious.


Thursday 31st of July 2014

Once you eat a perfect Panini (it takes just once) to be addicted to this specialty sandwich. My addiction and craving arising from the lingering memory of the perfect panini I had once makes me yearn for this beloved food. I scour the internet looking for every trace, mention, recipes, books, blogs, utensils etc that will lead me to a perfect panini again.... and then to be evermore intensified in my panini addiction. Then I discover your (old) blog, which is still as new as ever.

Kristen, your blog (May 26, 2010) pictorially laid out the steps to making a great panini. It was also a fabulous enabler to my panini addiction. It incited my craving to devour another panini. Please don't think you did anything wrong. This, my only addition, is the best of all the additions anyone could have :)

Panini: The best of all sandwiches. Buttery crisp and crunchy on the outside with nostalgic grill marks. Inside deliciously soft and gooey and a bite into pleasing veggies and satisfying meat of your choice.


Sunday 12th of January 2014

Thanx for the panini information. This one page answered about 8 questions for me. Thank You!


Saturday 9th of March 2013

Umm...Bricks anyone??

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.