Skip to Content

It’s time for the annual cookie guessing game!

cookie decorating

Every year, the kids and Mr. FG and I decorate cut-out Christmas cookies together.

cookie decorating

This started out as a fairly normal tradition, but somewhere along the way, we started putting eyes on our cookies.

cookie decorating

(I think Joshua may have started it with his grumpy cookie from years ago.)

grumpy cookies

And ever since then, our Christmas cookie container has been full of characters.

fg Christmas cookies

The worried bell on the right here makes me laugh.   And the tie?   Love it.

patrick star cookie

fg christmas cookies

(That’s an abominable snowman on the bottom, by the way.)

Anyway, a few years ago, we started a fun guessing game here on the blog, where I post six cookies, one made by each of us, and you guys have to guess who made each cookie.

The first person to get it right wins a $50 Amazon electronic gift code from me!

Would you like to meet this year’s subjects?

First up, we have a fish-lipped Christmas tree named Bertha, complete with a white beehive hairdo.

Bertha cookie

Next up is a nameless angry candy cane.

angry candy cane

Then a kind of worried Christmas tree.

worried Christmas tree

This snowman is wearing a tank top (which is considered to be rather un-stylish on men by the inhabitants of my house) and track pants, with stripes down the side.

snowman in track pants

Up next, a cute snowflake.

cute snowflake cookie

 

And lastly, we have a mad scientist Christmas tree, with spectacles and a goatee made out of a small Christmas tree candy.

mad scientist cookie

And the six cookie artists are Mr. FG, me, Joshua (16), Lisey (14), Sonia (11), and Zoe (9).

(There’s a picture of all of us on my about page, if you need to take a peek at our faces before you guess.   😉 )

Here are the numbered cookies:

 

IMG_7174frame

So, leave a comment with the cookie numbers in order, with your cookie artist guess following the number.

(We gotta keep them in numerical order so I don’t lose my mind trying to keep track of who got it right first!)

Ready?   Set?   Go!

P.S.  Here’s the Christmas cookie recipe I use.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Debra Beeuwsaert

Thursday 10th of December 2015

Cookie 1 - Joshua 2 - Mr FG 3 - Lisey 4 - Zoe 5 - Sonia 6 - FG

Stacey

Tuesday 8th of December 2015

1. Sonia 2. Joshua 3. Lisey 4. Zoe 5. Kristen 6. Mr. FG

Bonnie

Tuesday 8th of December 2015

And I think: 1. Zoe 2. Josh 3. Kristen 4. Sonia 5. Mr FG 6. Lisey

Ashes

Tuesday 8th of December 2015

Shot in the dark!

1. Zoe 2. Lisey 3. Kristen 4. Sonia 5. Mr. FG 6. Joshua

I really enjoy this every year. You'd think these monsterish creations would be more of a Halloween tradition, so it just tickles me that they're your family's Christmas Cookies. :D

Diane G

Tuesday 8th of December 2015

1. Zoe, 2. Lisey, 3. Kristen, 4. Sonia, 5. Mr. FG, 6. Joshua

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.