What if being kind to yourself actually works better?

For much of my life, I have spoken to myself like a drill sergeant.

"Work harder! You didn't do that right! Fix it! What is wrong with you? Why are you struggling? You're tired? That doesn't matter!"

fall leaves.

I suppose the drill sergeant method has its place in the world. Like, in military boot camps.

However, I have not found it to be particularly great in my own head. It does make me keep going, and it can make me turn out prodigious amounts of work. But it also has some serious downsides, such as...exhaustion and feeling beaten-down and insufficient as a person.

A kind voice trial

I don't think going into drill sergeant mode is the only way to get things done. In my work at the hospital, I do not operate as a drill sergeant, and yet, I do manage to be effective. I lead with kindness and compassion, and I express empathy, and that combo often leads to willing cooperation from the patient.

yellow fall leaf.

I also have noticed that this is helpful inside my own head. One night shift, about a year ago, I was having a trying time because my patient assignment included some very confused patients, self-removal of tubes (!!), and a patient getting out of bed despite being put in four-point soft restraints (for safety).

I was walking down the hall toward the room for the millionth time, on the verge of tears, and I realized I wasn't being very nice to myself in my head about this. The sound in my brain was something like, "What's wrong with you? Why are you about to cry over this? People do this work all the time! Stop being such a baby."

Kristen at night in hospital window.

So, I switched it up, and I told myself, "I am dealing with a really challenging situation, and even though I am very tired, I am doing a good job of being kind and patient."

Somehow, that little switch instantly made me a little lighter on my feet. And, importantly, I felt more energized for the task ahead of me (which did involve sitting at the bedside for hours and having circular conversations about the fact that it was indeed nighttime, and nighttime is for sleeping, not for getting out of bed.)

Acknowledge instead of minimizing

I tend to beat myself up by minimizing the challenge I'm facing, so the antidote is the opposite: acknowledging that this is a lot.

dogwood leaf in fall.

For me, this is helpful because it legitimizes the struggle, burnout, or exhaustion I'm feeling. Then, instead of feeling like something is wrong with me, I feel like my struggling makes sense.

And once I stop beating myself up for struggling, I find I have more energy to deal with whatever the struggle is. As it turns out, beating myself up may be a wasteful use of precious energy. 😉

What if you used a kind voice about your finances?

I was thinking about this recently in terms of finances. If you have been beating yourself up about your financial situation, or your spending, and it hasn't been helping, what if you tried being kind to yourself?

poison ivy leaf in fall.

What if you said to yourself, "I am facing a really big challenge, trying to make this amount of money cover all these expenses. Lots of people would find this hard, and I am no exception."

Then see how you feel. I'm guessing you might take a big breath and you might feel a little bit more at ease (and hopefully more up to the task!).

If you are feeling weary of packing lunches or making dinners, you could tell yourself, "Making this much food day in and day out is a lot! And I have been doing this for a long time. No wonder I feel tired of it sometimes." And that might be enough to get you out of a slump.

Your mileage may vary

I am nowhere near an expert on human psychology, and I acknowledge that there may be people out there who respond positively to an inner drill sergeant. So, if you've got one of those in your head and all is well, I am not saying you should change anything.

But if your drill sergeant is making you feel discouraged, exhausted, and insufficient, then maybe try on a kinder, gentler voice, and see what happens.

Tell me about your experience! Do you have a drill sergeant in your head? And have you ever tried a kinder voice?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

59 Comments

  1. ooh i LOVE this post/concept Kristen (as a definite drill sergeant, ESP when stressed and overwhelmed). It's a beautiful reminder. The key is treating yourself with the same care as you treat others you love, I think!

  2. I have a drill sargeant in my head, for sure.
    I am 47 years old, and I don't know if it was the 1980s, or New England, or my working class parents, or my Catholic upbringing, or some combination of it all, but I heard a singular message when I was younger -- that the path to success (and security which meant happiness) was hard work, hard work, and more hard work. Suck it up, do it anyway, keep going, don't show any weakness.
    I see things very differently now. And while I won't get into that all that, I am happy to see more approaches to - and acceptance in -- our world. Now there is more acknowledgment that we are all different, that we all experience challenges, that anxiety is real, and that harder/faster/more maybe doesn't work for all. There are so many ways to be. To get from A to Z. Or maybe you never get to Z and that's okay too.
    I wish someone had told me this when I was younger. I wish someone had encouraged me to treat myself with kindness, grace, and love. I was so hard on myself for so many years and I did not, do not deserve it. I am trying to do this for my kids now and we often talk about being a friend to yourself first.

    1. I needed this so much today. I am handling many very difficult things in my life right now. I'm starting to break down a bit and spent the day berating myself for my nervous system not being able to handle the load. This post made me realize that what I'm shouldering would be a lot for anyone. Maybe I can give myself some grace and credit. Thank you.

  3. For at least my adult life (about as far back in my inner monologue as I can remember!), I have normally talked to myself in a positive way. I was actually in the military - I think speaking kindly to myself then was even more of a boon when others were not always speaking as kindly to me as it is a constant reminder that someone else's thoughts are their own and I can think of myself differently. I figured everyone's internal monologue was generally upbeat like mine until I had post partum depression and found out how much your own brain can lie to you and be mean to itself. Good on you for recognizing your thought patterns weren't working for you and making the big effort to change your thoughts; that can be so hard to implement, so congratulations to anyone trying this when it is not their nature!

  4. I'm trying to do this as well, and really liked Sharon Izadi's The Kindness Method - along the same lines. I've beaten myself up for years over the same things that settled in childhood as so, so many of us do that it's nothing new, but trying to end the negative, hurtful thoughts. I'm on board with this kind of thinking!

  5. This is such a wonderful and helpful post! Thank you so much. I'm dealing with a difficult relationship right now and I keep telling myself I should be more patient, kinder, etc. Turning it around and acknowledging that this is a tough situation and I'm doing the best I kind makes such a difference.

  6. This post came at the right time for me, as I am facing some new challenges, and I have been feeling stressed. Remembering to be kind to myself is key.

    I have never had a drill sergeant in my head, but I've had a few in my circle, and it's also good to remember that their thoughts are their own, and you don't have to take them as gospel.

    1. Sending you a hug, Beth.
      Keep in mind when someone in your circle starts a sentence with "you should..." Picture them pointing a finger at you while they really are pointing three fingers back at themselves. Unsolicited opinions or advice are to be taken with a grain of salt. I most of the time tell them thanks for thinking of me and I'll give it some thought. Usually stops the barrage.

  7. I wish this could work for me, especially with my weight struggles, but I was raised in the era of drill sergeant parents and years of trying just can't remove that negative voice.
    On a side note, your night experience reminded me of when I worked in a nursing home on night shift and a man got out of his restraints and jumped out a second floor window. I was working the first floor and saw him fly past the window. This was after they had closed a nearby mental hospital and sent the elderly patients to us. The nursing home was ill equipped to handle these folks.

  8. I also have to remind myself that just because other people are going through harder things, my problems can still be hard for me. Yes, things could be worse. But it's ok to be overwhelmed by my own situation.

    Also, it's so helpful to have a conversation where someone simply acknowledges the challenge rather than trying to fix it. Sometimes we need help fixing but sometimes we just need an empathetic ear. I try to remind myself of this before giving advice.

    Everyone can use more kindness in their life. <3

    1. Oh, this really hit home. I, too, compare myself to others and think "it shouldn't be this hard for me. People are doing this AND taking care of children!" Your words about how, yes, I can still be overwhelmed with my life, no matter what are so true.

  9. I am a drill sargeant. Perhaps not surprising, given my father was a military officer. 🙂

    I don't see it as a bad thing, though. It does pretty much work for me to just put my head down and power through. Although, I don't think my inner monologue is that negative. More just demanding. And I see it as a positive to be demanding of myself. And sometimes others. But demanding of achievable excellence, not of perfection. There is a difference.

    So maybe that's not a drill sargeant? Not sure.

    1. Yes, sometimes we just need someone to hear us and say: Yes, of course it's OK to feel this way and gently remind us that this, too, shall pass.

      Today is not tomorrow and tomorrow is not the day after
      Don't deny how you feel, but don't dwell on it and don't let your emotions rule your behavior.

      What does it say about our society and how people parent that so many have these drill sargeants filling our heads 24/7?

  10. I have been working very hard these last months recognizing voices that developed in my head as a child in response to fear and chaos. One of the voices is "You are not enough." As a result of this voice, I have automated a near crippling response of "If you are productive, you will be enough. Did you work hard enough today?"

    As a result of these voices, I sit in judgement of myself often. When I am exhausted, drained or even just resting, I put myself through trial proving what I got "done" today. I suffer from scary depressions. You can imagine what this voice does to me when I am down. As you say in your article, these voices if anything are counterproductive in a given situation.

    I have two ways to challenge these voices that have been very helpful.

    1. Metacognitive Thinking: These negative voices have become a default in my brain. I practice noticing and manually overriding them. I started this technique with gratitude lists: I am thankful for the ability to pause when agitated and doubtful; I am thankful for friends and family I trust to recognize my stinking thinking; I remember I no longer regret the past nor am I beholden to the guilt it use to produce. These thoughts I earned through working the 12 steps of AA; careful therapy work; and acts of self care.

    2. Redefining Productivity: One time I was in a AA meeting. A woman took a 3 year sobriety chip. After the meeting she came up to me and said thank you to me. She told me at her first meeting I went up to her, shook her hand and said, "Keep coming back." She said that made all the difference. At 62, I am beginning to realize that quiet activities and stillness can make all the difference - watching my husband build a fire, validating a friend, patience with people fumbling in a check out line, praying for a lost soul.

    If I allow myself to be still and know I am enough, good things happen.

    1. "I remember I no longer regret the past nor am I beholden to the guilt it used to produce."
      This was a new way of thinking to me. Thank you!

      And YES to the small things like welcoming the woman to keep coming back. We don't knowhow much those brief (and perhaps forgotten) interactions mean.

  11. The way we speak about ourselves and to ourselves matters.
    Beating yourself up doesn't work for me and many others but so many continue to do this.

    Your body doesn't need to hear all the negative, self-judgment stuff. You can acknowledge that areas of your life need work to improve and that sometimes quite frankly you are not up to it and must rest, relax and renew before you are fit to tackle tough stuff.

    Give yourself the break you would give to someone you love who is beating themselves up. Self care is not indulgence or a reward.

  12. Kristen, I could have written this post (if I had a blog 😅), including the overwhelming night shift assignment - I have shut myself in the utility room more than once to pull myself together.
    I realized in therapy that I would NEVER speak to another human being the way I speak to myself. I learned about self compassion practices and how catch myself when my inner voice was mean. I would counter it by imagining what I would say to my young children if they came to me upset or sad or frightened. Kristin Neff is a professor of educational psychology out of UT Austin who teaches about self compassion practices; she is worth looking up if you struggle in this area or are looking for practices to help foster a kinder inner voice. Let’s aim to be as kind to ourselves as Kristen FG is to us 🙂

  13. I swear you wrote this for me today. My credit card bill is astronomical because of a manic episode, and now I'm trying to figure out how to pay it down without working myself into the ground doing delivery gig work. I've been so hard on myself lately, and I really should be kinder.

    I can tell other bipolar sufferers that it's okay, it's not their fault, it's a legitimate health issue, and when in the throes of a manic episode you can't always make yourself see reality. But I beat myself up over it when I have the out-of-control episodes.

    Thank you for the reminder to speak more kindly to myself.

    1. Felicia, I’m cheering for you as you work through this struggle and as you practice being kinder to yourself!

  14. Before I go to sleep each night, I do a little review and ask myself, "Have you done something kind for a friend or stranger? Something kind for your family (of origin or of choice)? And have I been kind to myself?" A kindness may be a small thing like letting the person behind you in the checkout line go ahead of you, letting a car turn into your lane,returning a wayward grocery cart to the corral, or taking in the neighbor's garbage cans. Making a favorite dish for my family or running an errand for our daughter who has a demanding job. And being kind to myself can be as simple as being gentle and forgiving when I messed up.

  15. I was introduced to the idea of an internal voice when I listened to the By The Book* podcast about this book: What to Say When You Talk to Yourself by Shad Helmstetter. (I didn't read the book, just listened to the podcast about it.) I realized I am very tolerant with myself but when I asked my husband did he ever talk to himself unkindly, he responded, "All the time". It was an eye-opener how different these conversations can be in another's head.

    * By The Book podcast hosts Jolenta Greenberg and Kristen Meinzer. Don't know the episode number but it aired Jan 25, 2018. (Not to be confused with another podcast of the same name about the Bible.)

  16. I don't have a drill sergeant as such but sometimes I don't think I'm as capable as others. What helps me is to think about what the barriers are in this situation, and then to break them down. What is preventing or challenging me from achieving/doing better at this issue? What advice would I give to someone else? I try and figure it out from there and I always ask for help if I need it (or for someone to let me vent!).

  17. A dear friend once asked me, after I'd called myself dumb doing something incorrectly, "Would you let anyone else talk to you that way? Then don't say that about yourself, either." That was a HUGE lightbulb moment in how I'd been taught to chastise/order myself around vs. more self encouragement and giving myself credit for trying/dealing with something difficult.

    To be clear, this isn't a toxic positivity approach, but a constructive way to remind myself I'm only human, and sometimes life is A LOT.

  18. Having very strict, ugly parents and a grandmother-babysitter who were overly strict, demanding and authoritarian, I had a really harsh inner critic and a sad, bad life for years. I was painfully shy because if I opened my mouth and said the wrong thing I was physically punished and/or ridiculed and yelled at. I internalized a lot of this hatefulness. Then, as an adult, I took a Self-Esteem Enhancement personal psychology course -- and it was a life changer! I became kinder and gentler to myself--more tolerant-- and learned to not put up with the barrage of negativity aimed at me. In fact, a turning point came when I stood up to my mother and told her "my worst enemy does not talk to me the way you do." My Unity pastor was also very helpful in these matters and she told me to don't say anything in reply but just stand up, walk out and go home when they got nasty. I did. It worked. (As Dr. Phil later said, you teach people how to treat you.) My inner critic has also been silenced and I listen for the "still small voice within" -- the Holy Spirit -- to guide me in my decisions. If someone is extremely ugly to me, as some relatives have been, I go no-contact. But I have silenced the inner critic and replaced it with a more loving attitude. My life today is calmer and happier and more peaceful.

    1. good for you. i went no contact with my step-mother after my dad passed. She made Cinderella's step-mother look like a pussycat. I am glad you made it to the other side.

  19. I worked in trauma icu at the VA for 5 years. I took the approach that the patient already had a drill servant in their head, I was the cheerleader. If it was a hard situation, my goal was to get the person to focus on anything pleasant for the next minute and remind them of the good things going their way versus the scary things that might happen.
    Take a cleansing breath, focus on the next minute and so on.
    My mom was having a difficult time, partly with the time change, she went to bed and was up an hour later. I encouraged her to do her night routine again, this time I turned on her heated mattress pad, sat next to bed, she fell asleep for the next 9 hours.
    Kindness is the only thing that works with her dementia, if I get frustrated, she reacts violently.
    Life is already hard, the least we can do is be kind to ourselves which will trickle down kindness to everyone else. <= got that off a poster of a waterfall my daughter designed in middle school.

  20. I have to remember this a lot with parenting! Not sure if there are other parents here who have read or listened to Dr. Becky but she often says (in reference to parenting moments) “This feels hard because it is hard.”

  21. Kristen, I love this. As the daughter of a VERY critical, perfectionist German mother, I have always had a drill sergeant/mean voice in my head telling me what an idiot I am and how everything I do is wrong. Sigh. I always made a conscious effort NOT to raise my daughter (now 25) as I was raised. I found it much easier to treat her with kindness, to be patient when she made a mistake, to encourage her gently. But I could never be that way with myself in my own head. Six months ago, I finally began going to therapy at age 59 because my daughter told me I was starting to act like my mom in the things I said to her and her girlfriend (who live with my husband and me). At first, I was really defensive, and had a list of legitimate reasons why I was so stressed and burned out {like having a fourth adult move in with us! 😉 }and maybe if I spoke more sharply these days, everyone could just cut me some slack. Later, I was so horrified that I had been acting that way. My therapist has helped me so much---I now catch myself saying terrible things to myself and it's easier to stop harsh words from coming out of my mouth towards others as well. But of course, it takes more than 6 months to change a lifetime of negative self talk. The other day, I was talking to my daughter and said I'd done something stupid, "because stupid is my brand". She stopped me and gently said "I think your brand is doing things with love and care". I was floored. (And grateful that we sent her to therapy starting when she was 14 and diagnosed with an difficult chronic illness---she's had 5 colonoscopies in 11 years!---so that she has such a high emotional IQ. ) Now I say that to myself sometimes, when I catch myself saying something mean. So yes, I also recommend trying a kinder and gentler voice!

    1. Awww, I love that you have begun seeing a therapist and that it has been helpful! I also love that your daughter is helping you speak more nicely to yourself. So many good things, and I am proud of you! 🙂

  22. We have moved my 98 year old mother into assisted living and she really, really doesn't want to be there. I have taken over paying the bills and paperwork - from afar - and it is a very frustrating experience for my family. I definitely have a drill sergeant in my head lately and haven't given myself grace. I love this take on mindset and will be giving it a try. Excellent post, Kristen!

    1. Elder care is so, so hard. You can only understand it if you're there. I'm in the same situation and it's breaking me. Good luck to you.

  23. YES! I also have a drill sergeant in my head, too! I think it motivated me for a lot of years and now it doesn't anymore. I feel like the Holy Spirit has been teaching me to speak more kindly to myself. You hit the nail on the head with this post.

  24. That voice in my head has ruled my life. (along with an emotionally abusive first marriage). When it starts to take over now, I recognize it and think of something nice and uplifting. Today I looked out my window and saw a beautiful tree with a yellow vine (grapevine I think) trailing to the ground. Kristen, your pics of leaves reminded that simple things can uplift us. And other replies here remind me that when people speak down or rudely to me they must be dealing with something and they are taking it out on me and I mentally say a prayer for them.

    1. Oh yes, emotional abuse in a marriage can definitely cause this. The other person's unkind voice takes up residence in your head, and it is hard to get it back out.

  25. Thank you so much for a beautiful post! I also have a drill sergeant in my head, and I am also in the process of replacing that mean, old guy with a kind and loving grandma. The switch for me started to flip in the pandemic (I know it has been six years--it's been a journey). We had four little kids, and I was trying to finish a dissertation. I realized that the drill sergeant was not only wrong, but ineffective in the work I was trying to do. Wait, is it empathy and relating to other people or trying to lead other people to do what is right for them, that flipped both our switches? Maybe we pushed through all those years only to realize that when the going gets tough, toughness doesn't actually work all that well in the long run? Wow, is this what therapy feels like? I'm having all kinds of breakthroughs here. LOL

  26. This reminds me of the health benefits of gratitude (versus the deleterious mental/physical health impacts of grumbling/complaining/gossiping). I wonder if positive self-talk has similar benefits? It also seems to me that the ripple effects of this is increased patience and understanding of other people around us, not just of ourselves. Thank you for this post. I'm chronically hard on myself. I'm inspired to change my inner voice.

  27. Wow, so kind, such a nice way of relating to self & teaching others the same. Thank you for this post and inspiring mindset shift. And appreciate those hard and sometimes thankless shifts nurses do!

  28. I do a kinder internal voice as a general rule. Years of being hard on myself and making myself small and trying to be the ALL at home magnified my stress when I was grieving. In order not to sink, I had to learn to swim. So I became my own life coach. I have sayings in my head to remind me that no one is perfect except God, a done something is better than a perfect nothing, and you are learning. It has made a world of difference to me.

  29. i had a drill sergeant for a father even though he was actually a Lt. Colonel. nothing i ever did was good enough. i would die rather than treat my kids the way he treated me. but he was actually kinder than my mother if you can imagine such a thing.

    i am in the stage of life where my good friends are moving to independent living in other states or passing on. But it is nice to still be here mostly content and appreciating my many blessings

  30. I really like my "drill sergeant" head .....I find it motivates me to accomplish most tasks in my life (difficult or not)......If I do what the sergeant insists, I feel this tremendous reward of accomplishment. Perhaps my drill sergeant is not very drill like, but more of a strategic incentive reminder that dangles that reward of self confidence. But I'm a contrarian, and act to avoid the feeling of not having accomplished something. hah.

  31. This is a beautiful post. I’ve found the same approach has worked miracles in normalizing my eating patterns.

  32. This really resonated with me — I also have a drill sergeant voice, especially about money, and it usually leaves me feeling discouraged rather than motivated. The night-shift example was powerful, because simply acknowledging how hard the situation was seemed to give you more energy, not less. I am going to try the kinder wording the next time I catch myself beating myself up over a frugal slip, like skipping a packed lunch.

  33. I am going through such a similar thought process and rebuilding of how I'm motivated and operate in a different way than I did/could when I was younger. Some medical complications give everything an extra layer of accommodation these days. I'm VERY accustomed to accommodating for others, but not for myself! I was always adaptable and easy to manage ha. This phase of life has given me so much more understanding and compassion for the many differences and struggles that humans experience.

    I guess now that my friends have been gently screaming at me for over a year now, it is finally sinking in that I've been too hard on myself and need to realize at a deeper level that I can't fix everything sometimes. Just have to do the what I can with the realities I'm presented and continue to build a life with joy. Cheerfully live on less, as a wise person here states. Speaking of which, my income might be impacted very soon, and being unwell is expensive. The mindset and skills I've cultivated my whole life are continuing to prove fruitful.

    1. You have juggled so much in the last few years, and yes, you deserve to give yourself credit for that, and also give yourself a break. 🙂

  34. When I was depressed I thought tomorrow will be a better day.
    Asking a friend about being depressed, he said, No, he thought it would last forever. I was surprised that he thought that.